The pros and cons of employee stock options rarely get discussed with real numbers attached, which makes them easy to either overvalue or dismiss. For women in tech, who are often offered equity as a meaningful piece of total compensation, that gap matters even more. Options can turn into real wealth. They can also expire worthless. Both outcomes have happened to real employees at real, well-known companies, and knowing both stories helps you evaluate your own grant with clear eyes instead of hope alone.
The Real Pros and Cons of Employee Stock Options
A stock option gives you the right to buy company shares at a fixed strike price, regardless of what the market price does later. If the stock rises well above that price, the difference is yours to capture. If it doesn’t, the option can simply expire, worth nothing, and you’ve lost nothing more than the opportunity.
That asymmetry is the entire case for stock options, but it only holds true before you exercise. Unexercised options carry limited downside: if the stock never rises above your strike price, the most you lose is the opportunity, since you never paid anything. Once you exercise, you’ve paid real cash for the strike price, and a falling stock means a real loss, not just a missed opportunity. This is a particular risk for anyone exercising ISOs early to start the long-term capital gains clock, since that cash is now at risk before the stock’s future is known.
An option only has value once the stock price rises above your strike price. Below that line, called being “underwater,” the option is worth exactly nothing, no matter how many shares you hold.
The Upside, Illustrated: Microsoft’s 1986 IPO
Microsoft went public on March 13, 1986, at $21 a share. Over the next two decades, the stock split nine times as Windows became the standard operating system on personal computers worldwide. Employees who had accepted stock options as part of their compensation, including many in non-executive, non-technical roles, watched modest option grants compound into real wealth.
The IPO is widely credited with creating an estimated 3 billionaires and roughly 12,000 millionaires, the vast majority of them ordinary employees rather than founders or executives. It became one of the most cited examples in American business history of stock options working exactly as intended.
The Downside, Illustrated: WeWork’s Collapse
WeWork tells the other side of the story. The company had reached a $47 billion peak valuation in early 2019, and its stock options looked, on paper, like a similar opportunity. By the time it filed to go public that August, concerns over governance and the sustainability of its business model had already cut that valuation roughly in half. The IPO was withdrawn entirely in September.
Thousands of employees were laid off in the months that followed. Many who had accepted stock options as part of their pay found those options deeply underwater or worthless once the company’s valuation fell. A later buyout offer from SoftBank priced shares well below what many employees needed just to break even on their strike price, leaving the options with little or no real value for most of the people who held them.
The same story can happen at any company, public or private. A high valuation today says nothing about what your options will be worth by the time you can actually exercise and sell.
Who This Applies To
This applies most directly to women in tech deciding between an offer that leans heavily on stock options versus one that leans toward salary, and to women already holding options who are trying to judge what they’re actually worth. It matters most early at a private company, where the eventual outcome, IPO, acquisition, or nothing at all, is still genuinely unknown. It catches women off guard most often when they treat a paper valuation as guaranteed future cash rather than one possible outcome among several, especially when negotiating a first offer that includes equity for the first time.
What This Means for Your Own Grant
Neither story should be read as a prediction. Microsoft and WeWork represent the real range of outcomes, not the average one. What you can control is how you evaluate your own options rather than assuming either ending applies to you.
- Compare your strike price to the company’s most recent valuation to see how much room for growth actually exists.
- Ask what percentage of your total compensation the options represent, and whether you’d accept the offer on salary alone.
- Find out how liquid the shares actually are, and whether an IPO, acquisition, or tender offer is realistically likely.
- Understand your exercise window and what happens to unexercised options if you leave the company.
- Note your options’ expiration date, typically 10 years from grant for ISOs. If you never exercise and that date passes, the options are gone regardless of what the stock is worth. A career break or job change is an easy way to lose track of an old grant.
- Confirm whether your grant is incentive stock options (ISOs) or non-qualified stock options (NSOs), since the tax treatment differs significantly. ISO holders face a particular risk: exercising early can trigger the Alternative Minimum Tax (AMT) on the spread between the strike price and fair market value, even if you don’t sell a single share. This is worth modeling with a tax advisor before you exercise.
- Avoid concentrating too much of your net worth in a single company’s stock, even one you believe in.
I don’t think the lesson from Microsoft or WeWork is to chase options or to avoid them. It’s to treat them as what they are: a real financial asset with real upside and real risk, not a guaranteed number on a spreadsheet. Most of the women in tech I work with are handed an offer letter with equity in it and very little context for what it actually means. The employees who came out ahead in both stories were the ones who understood exactly what they held, and that understanding is available to you too.
Common Questions
What are the pros and cons of employee stock options?
The upside is the potential for outsized gains if your company’s stock rises well above your strike price, often for little or no cost until you exercise. The downside is that options can also become worthless if the stock falls, the company fails, or an IPO or acquisition never happens, and exercising them carries real cash and tax risk.
Can employee stock options really make you rich?
Yes, in the right circumstances. Microsoft’s 1986 IPO is one of the most cited examples, credited with creating thousands of millionaires among ordinary employees who took stock options as part of their compensation. But outcomes like this are the exception, not the norm.
Can employee stock options become worthless?
Yes. If the stock price never rises above your strike price, or the company fails or is acquired below the option’s value, the options can expire with no value at all. This has happened at well-known companies, not just small startups.
Are stock options better than a higher salary?
It depends entirely on outcome and risk tolerance. Options offer more upside if the company succeeds, but a higher salary is guaranteed regardless of what happens to the stock. Neither is universally better, it’s a tradeoff between certainty and potential.
What is the difference between employee stock options pros and cons for startups versus public companies?
At public companies, you can usually see the stock price and sell shares once exercised. At startups, the shares are illiquid until an IPO, acquisition, or tender offer happens, which may never come, making the risk side of the tradeoff considerably larger.
How do I know if my stock options are a good deal?
Look at your strike price relative to the company’s current valuation, how much of your total compensation the options represent, and how realistic a future liquidity event actually is. A tax or financial advisor can help you weigh this against a straight salary offer.
Where to Go From Here
Understanding the pros and cons of stock options matters most once you know the mechanics behind them. Revisit how to exercise stock options, how stock option vesting actually works, and ISO vs. NSO for the full picture. For the broader foundation, visit my Equity Compensation pillar page.
Trying to Weigh a Stock Option Offer Against Salary?
I help women in tech build a clear, confident plan around their equity compensation.
Book a Consultation